top of page

Establishing the Coaching Agreement

Sep 14
7 min read

Updated: Nov 12

Blush-colored plates and gold flatware arranged precisely on a deep forest green tablecloth.
Set the table. Then trust what happens around it.

There is a point when setting the table stops being hospitality.

The plates are out. The glasses are filled. Everyone has a place to sit. But the host is still adjusting the forks while the guests wait for dinner.

Coaching agreements can feel a little like that.

We can become so intent on establishing the outcome, defining success, exploring why it matters, and identifying what needs to be addressed that the opening of a coaching conversation begins to sound faintly like a deposition.

I rarely have that problem.

I tend to do the opposite.

After years of coaching, I have become pretty good at hearing an agreement take shape. A client begins talking, and somewhere in the story I hear it: Ah. That's what we're really here to explore.

And off we go.

Except sometimes the agreement exists mostly in my head.

I've intuited where we're going without pausing long enough to make sure the client and I are actually going there together.

That is the edge I'm paying attention to now: making the agreement explicit without making it mechanical.

Because the coaching agreement isn't something we have to get through before the coaching can begin.

When I Think I Know Where We're Going

Imagine a client who begins:

“I need to figure out whether I should leave my job.”

As a coach, I hear all sorts of possibilities in figure out. Does the client want to make a decision? Understand why the decision is difficult? Get clearer about what they want? Trust themselves enough to act on something they already know?

So I listen.

A few minutes later, the client says, “I've gone back and forth about this for six months. Honestly, if I could just understand why I keep second-guessing myself, that would be huge.”

There it is.

Or at least I think there it is.

My instinct would be to follow the second-guessing. The client has handed me a promising thread, and I'm curious about it.

But what if I pause first?

“You came in wanting to figure out whether to leave your job, and now I'm hearing that understanding the second-guessing might be particularly useful. What would you most like to walk away with today?”

Perhaps the client says, “Yes. That's exactly it. I want to understand why I don't trust myself.”

Or perhaps they say, “Actually, I know I second-guess myself. Today I really need to make the decision.”

And that's the catch: the small but important difference between what I heard and what the client actually wanted.

My intuition may have been useful. It simply wasn't an agreement yet.

The Coaching Agreement Is Created Together

I've spent enough time with the ICF evidence markers to know the language around agreements well. What catches my attention now is something I have probably said to other coaches many times: the language consistently points toward partnering—asking, reflecting, confirming, co-designing.

The coach isn't simply expected to understand what the client wants to accomplish. The understanding needs to be shared.

Which, when I put it that way, seems rather obvious.

And yet.

Knowing something about coaching and noticing exactly how it shows up in our own coaching are two different things.

I can see how easily an experienced coach might leave some of that partnership unspoken. We listen closely. We synthesize quickly. We hear what matters. The conversation feels clear to us, so we keep moving.

This doesn't mean I need to march through a prescribed series of questions:

  • What would you like to accomplish?

  • How will you know you've accomplished it?

  • Why is that important?

  • What do we need to address?

Sometimes those are exactly the questions the conversation needs. Sometimes the client has already answered three of them before I've had a chance to ask one.

A client might say:

“I've been avoiding this conversation with my boss for three months. I have another meeting with her tomorrow, and I don't want to chicken out again. I need to understand what's stopping me.”

There is quite a lot on the table already.

I don't need to ask, “What would you like to accomplish today?” as though I hadn't heard them.

I might simply reflect:

“You want to understand what's stopping you so you can go into tomorrow's meeting differently. Is that it?”

“Yes.”

“What feels important to understand about what's stopping you?”

The agreement is becoming more explicit, but we haven't stepped outside the coaching to establish it. We are already coaching.

The Occupational Hazard of Good Intuition

One of the occupational hazards of coaching for a long time is that we get pretty good at noticing things.

Patterns. Contradictions. The metaphor the client didn't seem to notice they used three times. The sentence that suddenly has more voltage than everything around it.

That sensitivity is useful.

It can also make it surprisingly easy to follow something fascinating that the client never actually asked us to explore.

Suppose a client is deciding whether to accept a promotion. Every time she talks about the new role, she mentions her father's expectations. I notice it immediately.

Perhaps this isn't really about the promotion. Perhaps it's about whether she can choose a life her father wouldn't choose for her.

That's interesting. It might even be true. But I don't actually know yet.

“I've noticed your father's expectations have come up several times as you've talked about this decision. What do you make of that?”

Maybe she pauses.

“Wow. I hadn't noticed that.”

Now we have somewhere interesting to go.

But even then, I might ask:

“Is that where you'd like to focus, or would it be more useful to stay with the decision itself?”

Same intuition. But now the client gets to decide what to do with it.

I see establishing the agreement as an exercise in humility. I can notice something without needing to be right about its importance. I can offer a thread without tugging the client down it. I can trust what I'm hearing enough to name it and trust the client enough to tell me whether it matters.

Coaching Agreements Are Allowed to Change

There is another place where my tendency to intuit can sneak in.

The agreement was clear at the beginning. Then something changes.

The client who wanted to understand why she hesitates around her boss begins talking about how small she makes herself around people she perceives as powerful. Her pace changes. There is more energy here. I can feel the conversation opening.

My coaching instinct says: Go there.

And maybe we should. It is worth asking.

“We started with what keeps you from speaking up with your boss, and now I'm hearing something broader about making yourself smaller around people with power. Where would you like to go from here?”

That question doesn't drag us back to the original agreement. It doesn't assume we should abandon it either. It simply makes the shift visible.

This is one of the things I appreciate about the progression toward mastery in the ICF material. The desired outcome isn't treated as a contract we sign in the first five minutes and then dutifully obey. The coach keeps it as a flexible guide, notices subtle shifts, and invites the client to choose a different direction when something new emerges.

Perhaps that is what greater fluency with the agreement looks like. Not less agreement, but less visible machinery. The structure is still there; it simply becomes more responsive to the conversation as it unfolds.

The agreement stays alive because the partnership stays alive.

A Fuzzy Coaching Agreement Can Make for Very Interesting Conversation

There is another reason I'm paying more attention to this.

I've listened to coaching sessions with wonderful moments in them. A beautiful question. A powerful observation. A long silence followed by something the client has clearly never said aloud before.

And still, at the end, something feels a little loose.

I've done this in my own coaching too.

The conversation is rich. We are exploring something meaningful. But somewhere along the way I find myself wondering: What exactly were we trying to accomplish again?

Without enough shared clarity about what the client wants from the conversation, almost any interesting thread can look coachable.

The childhood story may matter. The metaphor may matter. The tightening in the client's shoulders may matter. The contradiction I just heard may matter.

But matter to what?

This is where I have begun to appreciate the agreement less as an ICF requirement and more as something that helps me listen.

It helps me decide what to follow.

It also gives us somewhere to return.

If the client wanted to understand why she keeps second-guessing herself, I can eventually ask:

“You came in wanting to understand the second-guessing. What do you understand now that you didn't when we started?”

We don't need to perform a ceremonial closing of the agreement.

We are simply returning to a question the client told us mattered.

A Reflection for Coaches

I'm curious whether other experienced coaches might recognize themselves somewhere in this.

Perhaps your tendency is to overwork the agreement. You keep adjusting the forks because you want to be certain every piece is in exactly the right place before the coaching begins.

Or perhaps you're more like me. You can see the table. You have a pretty good idea where everyone is sitting. You assume the client can see it too.

The next time you listen to one of your own recordings, it might be interesting to listen specifically for what happened between those two extremes.

What did the client tell you before you asked?

What did you hear but never say aloud?

Where did you ask for clarification that genuinely served the client—and where did you ask a question they had essentially already answered?

When the conversation shifted, who decided to follow it?

And perhaps the simplest question of all: Did the client and I actually share an understanding of what this conversation was for?

I'm asking myself that one more often these days.

Hearing Ourselves Through Mentor Coaching

This is also why I continue to find recordings so useful in mentor coaching.

It is remarkably difficult to hear our own habits while we're busy doing them.

Another pair of ears can help us notice where we assume, where we overwork, where we rush past something, or where one small moment of clarification might create more partnership. Often the richest discoveries aren't about something a coach doesn't know. They're about something the coach knows so well that the way they're doing it has become invisibly habitual.

Maybe that's what I'm practicing now.

Not better agreement questions. Not more agreement questions.

Just making sure the agreement isn't a private arrangement between me and my own intuition.

I don't need to keep adjusting the forks.

I do need to make sure we both know where we're sitting.





ICF Mentor Coaching Specialization badge

bottom of page