The Subtle Art of Discernment in Coaching

Discernment helps coaches navigate the many choice points in a coaching conversation—instead of a dice roll, each moment invites the coach to sense the most resonant direction.

In the ever-evolving flow of a coaching conversation, there are moments when a coach must pause—not to think, but to sense. Imagine a pair of dice rolled between two people, each face representing a different conversational thread. The coach’s role isn’t to control the dice, but to notice which numbers show up—and choose which path to follow based not on probability, but on resonance. These moments of choice call for more than logic; they call for discernment. The coach must decide which thread to follow, which silence to honor, which question to ask, and whether to ask anything at all.

Discernment is a subtle but powerful undercurrent running through the ICF Core Competencies. Though not named explicitly, it is the bedrock of presence, listening, and partnership. It is what allows a coach to hold the whole of the client while making precise, courageous choices that catalyze insight and forward movement.

In this article, we’ll explore:

🔹 What discernment means in the context of coaching

🔹 How it aligns with the ICF Core Competencies

🔹 Typical choice points where discernment is essential

🔹 A story that brings discernment to life in a real coaching session

🔹 Ways coaches can cultivate and expand their capacity for discernment

Keep reading to learn ways to deepen your discernment prowess. 🎲🤔

---

Want to read more?

Subscribe to cindyhosea.com to keep reading this exclusive post.

Subscribe Now