top of page

Coaching Intuition: Something in the Air

Feb 21, 2025
6 min read

Updated: 1 day ago

Red-and-white windsock extending in the wind against a clear blue sky.
Coaching with intuition is like feeling a shift in the wind.

Sometimes an idea appears in a coaching conversation, as if out of thin air.

A client is speaking, and suddenly an image comes to mind. Or we feel drawn toward a question that has little obvious connection to what we've been discussing. We haven't deliberately analyzed the situation or worked our way through a series of possibilities. Something simply occurs to us.

And there it is, asking for our attention.

We call this intuition, although explaining exactly what we mean by that word can be surprisingly difficult.

I think of intuition a little like the wind. We can't see it directly, but we recognize its movement. A gentle breeze may be barely noticeable, while a sudden gust catches us by surprise.

Of course, noticing the wind doesn't mean we know where it's coming from, where it's going, or whether we ought to follow it.

And that's where intuition can become a bit perplexing in coaching.

The Curious Nature of Coaching Intuition

My Co-Active® training helped me appreciate intuition as a meaningful part of coaching, even when an impression arises without an explanation I can readily articulate. I've come to value that invitation to take our intuitive responses seriously without assuming they must always be accurate or useful.

Intuition may arrive as a feeling, an image, a connection, or an unexpected sense that something deserves attention. It can be subtle or surprisingly compelling.

What distinguishes it from ordinary observation is not necessarily what we notice, but how the impression comes to us.

We might observe that a client's voice has become quieter. That's something we can describe. Interpreting the change as hesitation introduces a possible explanation, although others may be equally plausible.

An intuition can be less straightforward. Perhaps the client's words suddenly remind us of a conversation from several sessions ago. Or an image of a closed door appears in our mind, even though neither of us has mentioned doors, entrances, exits, or anything remotely architectural.

Where did that come from?

Possibly from something we noticed without consciously registering it. Experience may have helped us recognize a pattern. Or the association could reflect something personal that has very little to do with the client.

We don't always know.

That uncertainty can make intuition feel mysterious, but it needn't make it either mystical or meaningless.

When Something Unexpected Appears

Imagine a client describing a promotion they've recently accepted.

They're pleased with the opportunity, excited about the responsibilities, and looking forward to what comes next. The conversation is moving along quite naturally when an image suddenly appears in the coach's mind: a bird in a cage.

It's an odd association. The client hasn't described feeling trapped, and there's no obvious reason to suspect they're unhappy.

The coach could ignore the image. Perhaps it has nothing to do with the conversation. But suppose the impression persists, and the coach decides it might be worth offering.

"An image just came to mind, and I'm not sure whether it has any relevance. I pictured a bird in a cage. Does that connect with anything for you?"

The client pauses.

"Not really. Actually, I was thinking about how this promotion will give me more freedom."

Well, there goes the bird.

Another client might respond quite differently.

"That's interesting. I've been excited about the promotion, but I am wondering whether I'll have less freedom than I do now."

The image hasn't revealed a hidden truth. It has introduced an unexpected possibility for exploration, and the client has decided what, if anything, to make of it. An intuition might open a meaningful conversation, lead somewhere entirely unexpected, or prove irrelevant to what the client wants to explore.

There can be something wonderfully creative about such exchanges. An association that appeared without warning becomes available to both people, neither knowing quite where it might lead.

The interesting part isn't that the coach thought of a bird. It's what becomes possible when an unexpected impression enters the conversation.

What Experience Contributes

It's tempting to describe intuition as something that exists apart from thinking, as though our minds occasionally abandon reason and consult a more mysterious source of wisdom.

I suspect the relationship is more complicated.

Over time, we accumulate experiences, recognize patterns, and become familiar with aspects of human behavior and conversation. Connections may occur quickly, before we're able to explain how we've arrived at them.

Research on intuitive expertise offers a useful perspective here. Psychologists Daniel Kahneman and Gary Klein have examined the conditions under which intuitive judgments can become reliable. Their work suggests that experience is particularly valuable when we have opportunities to recognize meaningful patterns and receive feedback that helps us learn from them.

Coaching presents an interesting complication.

Coaching conversations don't always offer the predictable patterns or reliable feedback that help intuitive expertise develop. A client may find an observation helpful without agreeing with its premise. Another may agree politely even when our interpretation misses the mark.

Experience can certainly enrich our intuition. It also gives us an impressive collection of familiar explanations that may or may not fit the person sitting in front of us.

Then there's the matter of what we bring into the conversation ourselves.

Our histories, preferences, emotions, and cultural assumptions influence what captures our attention. A coach who values independence may be particularly sensitive to anything resembling constraint. Someone who has experienced a difficult career transition may recognize echoes of that experience in a client's uncertainty.

These associations aren't necessarily problems to eliminate. They're part of being human, and occasionally they contribute something valuable.

But an impression that feels significant to us isn't automatically significant to the client.

The Other Half of Intuition

I've always appreciated the encouragement to trust our intuition in coaching. Many of us have been trained to justify our thinking, explain our reasoning, and avoid offering something unless we're reasonably certain it makes sense.

Intuition invites us beyond those familiar habits. But trusting an intuition doesn't necessarily mean speaking it aloud. This distinction matters.

Noticing an impression doesn't obligate us to act on it. Something may capture our attention without necessarily deserving the client's. The decision to introduce it calls for another kind of judgment.

An intuition might be compelling but irrelevant. It could arrive while the client is already making an important discovery, or reflect our own desire to understand something that hasn't yet become clear.

On another occasion, an unexpected impression may offer a possibility neither person has considered.

The question isn't simply whether we trust our intuition. It's whether we can exercise judgment about what to do with it.

That judgment involves more than deciding whether an impression is accurate. It also asks us to consider our own responses and motivations. Are we drawn to share something because it might serve the client's exploration, or because we're intrigued by what has occurred to us?

This doesn't mean suppressing our internal experience. Our impressions, emotions, and associations are part of what we bring to coaching. The challenge is to remain aware of their influence without allowing them to take over the conversation.

An intuition may invite us to speak. Discernment helps us consider whether speaking serves the client.

Even then, the way we share an impression matters. Offering it tentatively allows the client to make something of it without feeling responsible for confirming our interpretation.

After all, "I have a hunch" is an invitation, not a request for confirmation.

Developing a Relationship with Intuition

I don't think intuition becomes more useful simply because we become more willing to follow it.

Perhaps what develops with experience is a more thoughtful relationship with the impressions that arise.

We become familiar with how intuition shows up for us, recognizing occasions when an unexpected image or feeling has led somewhere interesting and others when we've attached more significance to it than the situation warranted.

Reflective practice can be particularly useful here.

After a coaching conversation, an intuition we shared may deserve another look. How did it influence the exchange? Were we invested in our interpretation? What did the client's response help us understand?

Equally interesting are the impressions we chose not to share.

Perhaps an intuition passed, and the conversation developed in a direction we hadn't anticipated. Looking back, we might recognize that an unasked question could have been worth exploring.

Or maybe leaving it alone was exactly what the moment needed.

The point isn't to become endlessly occupied with evaluating our intuition. That would be a rather unproductive way of getting in our own heads.

Reflection helps us become more familiar with our tendencies. Some coaches may discover that they dismiss intuitive impressions too readily. Others may find they're quite enthusiastic about sharing them, particularly when an unexpected metaphor strikes them as unusually clever.

There are worse professional habits, certainly. But a little curiosity about our own can be useful.

The Unexpected Guest

Perhaps the intrigue of intuition lies partly in its unpredictability. An image appears, a connection surprises us, or an unexpected question finds its way into the conversation. We hadn't planned for any of it.

There is a particular satisfaction in offering something unexpected and watching a client discover a meaning we never imagined. And a certain freedom in recognizing that even our most compelling intuitions don't require an audience.

A Moment for Reflection

Intuition can surprise us, but what we do with it deserves just as much attention. Consider your own experience:

  • How does intuition tend to show up in my coaching, and how readily do I recognize it?

  • When an impression feels particularly compelling, what might be influencing my interpretation?

  • How do I discern whether sharing an intuition will serve the client's exploration—or simply satisfy my own curiosity?

Not every nudge needs to be followed. Some are worth noticing and letting pass.



ICF Master Certified Coach digital badge

bottom of page