ICF Core Competency 3: Establishes and Maintains Agreements
Updated: Nov 7

Ever been on a road trip where no one agreed on the basics—where you're headed, how long you'll drive, or even who's holding the keys? One person wants the mountains, another has the beach in mind, and before long, everyone is sitting at a gas station arguing over snacks. Not exactly the adventure anyone imagined.
Coaching without clear agreements can feel much the same. There may be plenty of conversation, even moments of genuine insight, but coach and client can find themselves working toward different destinations without quite realizing it.
An agreement gives the relationship direction. It establishes a shared understanding of what we're doing together, why it matters, and how we'll recognize progress. Yet unlike a GPS that insists on recalculating every time we take an unexpected turn, a good coaching agreement leaves room for discovery. Sometimes the most meaningful destination isn't the one the client had in mind when the journey began.
Establishing and Maintaining Agreements: The Foundation of Partnership
ICF Core Competency 3, Establishes and Maintains Agreements, addresses two dimensions of coaching: the agreements that shape the overall relationship and those we establish within individual sessions.
Before coaching begins, we clarify what coaching is and isn't, discuss our respective responsibilities, and establish expectations about confidentiality, scheduling, fees, and other practical matters. We also explore the client's broader goals and whether the relationship feels like a good fit.
Some of this sounds rather administrative. Admittedly, discussing cancellation policies is unlikely to be anyone's favorite part of coaching. Yet these conversations create the conditions in which both people can participate with greater confidence and clarity.
Consider an organizational coaching engagement. A company sponsors coaching for one of its leaders, hoping to strengthen their effectiveness in a new role. The leader, meanwhile, wants to explore whether the role is right for them at all.
Both interests may be legitimate, but they aren't necessarily the same.
Without thoughtful agreements, the coach can find themselves caught between expectations nobody fully discussed. What information will be shared with the sponsor? Who determines the coaching goals? How will progress be understood, and what remains confidential?
These conversations require the client's participation. An agreement between coach and sponsor cannot quietly substitute for one with the person being coached.
We won't anticipate every complication. Human relationships have a remarkable talent for producing circumstances no contract writer ever imagined. But a shared understanding gives us something to return to when circumstances become more complicated.
A Conversation Within the Conversation
While engagement agreements provide the broader foundation, each session calls for its own understanding of what the client wants to accomplish.
A client may arrive wanting to discuss a difficult relationship with a colleague. We could explore what happened, what was said, and how the client responded. There may be plenty to talk about. But having a topic isn't quite the same as having an agreement.
Perhaps the client wants to prepare for a conversation. Perhaps they're trying to understand why this particular colleague provokes such a strong reaction. Or perhaps they're questioning whether the relationship can be repaired at all.
Each possibility suggests a different direction.
Establishing the session agreement invites the client to consider what would make our time together meaningful, why it matters, and how they'll recognize that the conversation has been useful.
This isn't a questionnaire to work through before we're allowed to begin. Sometimes the agreement emerges in a few sentences. At other times, clarifying the focus becomes valuable coaching in itself. The client may discover that what initially seemed urgent isn't quite what matters most.
There's also a distinction between hearing what a client wants and assuming we understand what they mean.
Words such as clarity, confidence, or balance can sound reassuringly specific until we discover that each of us has attached a different meaning to them. A coach might interpret confidence as a willingness to speak up, while the client means becoming more comfortable with uncertainty.
A little curiosity can prevent a great deal of well-intentioned wandering.
When the Conversation Changes Direction
Establishing an agreement is only part of the competency. We also have to maintain it.
That doesn't mean treating every unexpected insight as an unwelcome detour. It means remaining attentive to what the client wanted to accomplish and what is emerging in the conversation.
Imagine a client who begins a session wanting to prepare for an important presentation. As we explore their concerns, they mention that they've been questioning whether they want to remain in their current leadership role.
The conversation grows quieter. Something about that second concern seems to carry more weight.
It's tempting to follow it immediately. After all, this sounds like the more interesting issue, and coaches aren't entirely immune to the appeal of an intriguing discovery.
But our interest isn't the deciding factor.
We might acknowledge what we're noticing and invite the client to consider whether they want to stay with the presentation or explore the larger question. Either direction could be meaningful. The choice belongs to the client.
Sometimes the client wants to continue with the original topic. The new awareness may matter, but not be something they wish to explore today. At other times, the agreement changes as the conversation takes an unexpected turn.
Neither outcome suggests that the original agreement was inadequate. It provided an initial direction, and revisiting it allows that direction to evolve.
The same principle applies across an engagement. Goals established several months ago may no longer reflect the client's circumstances or priorities. Maintaining the agreement means remaining willing to reconsider what we're working toward.
The Partnership Beneath the Agreement
With experience, establishing agreements often becomes more natural. We learn to recognize what matters and notice when a conversation begins to drift. Yet maintaining an agreement involves more than keeping the conversation on track. Sometimes the track itself is no longer taking the client where they want to go.
There's a delicate balance here. Too little structure, and we risk a pleasant conversation that never quite finds its purpose. Too much, and we may become so committed to the original agreement that we miss what the client is discovering. The agreement gives us something to return to, not something we must defend.
This spirit of partnership carries through the relationship, including its eventual conclusion. Ending well deserves more attention than noticing we've reached the last appointment on the calendar. It's an opportunity to reflect together on what has changed, acknowledge what remains unfinished, and consider how the client wishes to carry their learning forward. Not every goal will have been neatly accomplished, and that's worth making room for, too.
There's freedom in working this way. Neither coach nor client needs to know every turn the conversation will take. We can begin with a clear direction, remain curious about what emerges, and trust the partnership enough to reconsider our plans when something important changes.
After all, a coaching agreement isn't a promise that we'll arrive exactly where we expected. It's a way of making sure we're still traveling together—and that the client hasn't quietly decided they'd rather go somewhere else.

Read other articles in the ICF Core Competencies series.
These reflections represent my own interpretation of the ICF Core Competencies and Code of Ethics, rather than official ICF guidance.




