Coaching Through Change
Updated: 2 days ago

A hermit crab has an interesting relationship with its home.
Unlike creatures that grow their own protective shells, hermit crabs inhabit shells left behind by others. As they grow, they eventually need to find something larger. A shell that once provided shelter becomes increasingly restrictive, and the crab must venture out to find another.
There is a vulnerable moment between shells. The old one no longer fits, but the new one isn't yet secure. And finding a suitable replacement isn't necessarily straightforward. The crab may inspect several possibilities before settling into one that accommodates its changing body.
I've been thinking about hermit crabs lately.
After years of coaching executives through reorganizations, professionals through career transitions, and leaders through the peculiar experience of discovering that their organizations no longer have quite the same place for them, I'm navigating a professional transition of my own.
It's a curious experience to be on the other side of questions I've asked hundreds of times. What matters now? What are you ready to leave behind? What possibilities are emerging?
Knowing the questions, it turns out, doesn't make the answers arrive any faster.
And perhaps that's what interests me most about change. Not simply how we adapt to new circumstances, but how those circumstances reveal the identities we've outgrown, the attachments we hadn't recognized, and the possibilities we haven't yet imagined.
How does change shape who we are becoming?
The Identities We Protect
Organizations have a remarkable talent for making change sound administrative.
Departments are realigned. Reporting structures are adjusted. Resources are redistributed. Strategic priorities evolve. Sometimes the language is so carefully neutral that you might forget actual human beings are involved.
But for someone who has spent years building something, developing relationships, and becoming known for a particular contribution, a change in the organizational chart can feel like a change in the story of their life.
I've coached people who were genuinely ready to leave their organizations but were surprised by how difficult leaving became. They could list a dozen reasons to move on, yet when the opportunity finally arrived, they hesitated.
Sometimes what they were reluctant to surrender wasn't the job itself. It was the identity that came with it: being the trusted advisor, the problem solver, the person everyone consulted. Sometimes it was the sense of belonging to an institution whose reputation had become intertwined with their own.
We rarely think of these things as possessions. We don't list them among our benefits or negotiate them in our employment contracts. Yet they can become surprisingly difficult to relinquish.
Change has a way of revealing attachments we didn't know we had.
When a client says, "I don't know who I'll be without this job," we might be tempted to reassure them that their skills and accomplishments belong to them, not to the organization. True enough, but perhaps not particularly illuminating.
What if we became curious instead?
What does this role allow you to believe about yourself?
What are you afraid might disappear when you leave?
Which parts of your identity belong to you, regardless of where you work?
These questions invite clients to explore something beyond the practical decision. They begin to distinguish the role they've occupied from the person who has been occupying it.
And sometimes they discover that the role has been doing considerably more identity maintenance than they realized.
When the Old Shell No Longer Fits
Not all change arrives through an organizational announcement. Some of it happens so gradually that we barely notice the distance between the life we're living and the one we originally designed.
A responsibility expands. A family member needs more support. Our energy changes. What once seemed manageable begins to require more than we have available. Eventually, we find ourselves reconsidering decisions that made perfect sense when we made them.
As my son's caregiving needs have evolved, I've been redesigning my coaching practice to create more flexibility around family responsibilities. It's work I still love, but the structure that once supported my professional life no longer fits quite so well.
That realization has prompted some uncomfortable questions. Which parts of my work energize me, and which have I continued largely because they're what I've always done? What do I want my work to contribute beyond income or recognition? And which ambitions still belong to the person I am becoming, rather than the person I was when I first imagined them?
There's a peculiar discomfort in reconsidering something we once pursued wholeheartedly. We can feel as though changing direction invalidates the effort that brought us here, or that choosing a different kind of professional life means settling for less.
But a decision doesn't become wrong simply because our circumstances change.
Of course, not every change represents a freely chosen reinvention. Caregiving, illness, financial pressures, and organizational decisions can impose real limitations. Agency is not the same as unlimited freedom, and a sufficiently positive attitude cannot overcome every constraint, despite what some motivational posters would have us believe.
Sometimes the more interesting coaching questions are not about what the client wants to achieve, but about what they are reconsidering.
What made this arrangement right for you when you chose it?
What's different about you or your life now?
What are you still trying to make work that may no longer fit?
If you weren't trying to preserve the life you planned, what might you want to create with the life you have?
That last question is one I've been sitting with myself.
Perhaps the next chapter isn't about building something bigger, but about creating something more intentional. I'm still discovering what that means in practice, although I have no shortage of ideas. Give me an unexpected opening in my calendar and I can fill it with three new projects before lunch.
Apparently, leaving room for the unknown requires more discipline than filling it.
Who We're Becoming
One of the things I've noticed in coaching conversations is how quickly people want to replace an old identity with a new one.
If they're leaving an executive role, they want to know what they'll be next. If they're retiring, they want a purpose. If they're changing careers, they want a compelling new professional narrative. An unfinished answer to the question What do you do? can feel surprisingly uncomfortable.
So we begin constructing a new answer before we've fully understood what we're leaving.
I've come to appreciate the importance of that unfinished space. Without familiar responsibilities and expectations, we may discover things about ourselves that weren't particularly visible before. Perhaps we enjoy work we once considered too small for our ambitions. Perhaps we're less willing to make compromises we once accepted without question. Or perhaps something we've kept at the margins of our lives begins to matter more than we expected.
In coaching, this is where I become especially curious.
What are you noticing about yourself that surprises you?
What feels different about the way you're responding to things?
What are you discovering that you might not have noticed if nothing had changed?
Who are you becoming that you haven't quite found the words for yet?
The questions aren't intended to extract a positive lesson from a difficult experience. Some changes are genuinely painful, unfair, or unwelcome. We don't have to celebrate what has happened to become curious about who we are within it.
Nor do we need to turn every transition into a personal transformation project. Sometimes people simply need to make a decision, pay the mortgage, or get through a difficult week.
But when a client begins to notice something new about themselves, the coaching conversation has an opportunity to move beyond managing circumstances toward exploring identity.
The coach doesn't need to know where that exploration will lead. In fact, assuming we know would probably get in the way.
Coaching Through Change
We often approach change as a problem to be solved or a transition to be completed. Something happens, we adapt, and eventually we emerge with a new plan, a clearer identity, or a renewed sense of purpose.
Human beings, however, are rarely so obliging.
We can make a good decision and still feel sad. We can leave something behind without knowing what will replace it. We can discover new possibilities while wishing the circumstances that revealed them had never occurred.
Perhaps one of the most valuable things we can offer clients navigating change is the freedom to be unfinished. To reconsider an identity without immediately replacing it, acknowledge a loss without being hurried toward gratitude, and explore possibilities without committing to a destination before they're ready.
The next time a client brings a significant change into the coaching room, I want to listen for more than the problem they're trying to solve or the decision they're trying to make.
I want to listen for the person who is becoming visible through the change. Including, perhaps, to themselves.
This essay is part of Coaching Through Everything, a series exploring the wonderfully complicated human experiences that find their way into coaching conversations—and what they ask of us as coaches.





