Coaching Through Self-Explanation
Updated: Nov 7

One of the greatest hazards of becoming self-aware is becoming convinced that you already are.
It happens quietly. We begin to understand ourselves. We recognize our patterns. We learn the language of personality, attachment, strengths, trauma, emotional intelligence, or neuroscience. We can explain why we hesitate, why we overwork, why we avoid conflict, or why we seek approval.
Those explanations are often true. They are also deeply comforting.
Eventually, without realizing it, we stop observing ourselves because we have become so good at describing ourselves.
I've noticed this in coaching clients. I've also noticed it in coaches (including myself).
Coaching through self-explanation begins with a simple distinction: explaining ourselves is not the same as observing ourselves.
Explanation tells us why we behaved as we did yesterday. Observation notices what is happening today.
The first gives us understanding. The second gives us choice.
And choice is where change begins.
Every Explanation Solves a Problem
Human beings are natural meaning-makers. We long to understand ourselves. Every explanation is an attempt to make the world a little more predictable.
Every genuine insight becomes another brick.
Brick by brick, we construct a story that explains who we are, how we got here, and why we respond the way we do. Understanding ourselves brings relief. It transforms confusion into coherence.
There is nothing wrong with that wall.
We built it for good reasons. It helps us make sense of painful experiences. It reminds us that our behavior is understandable rather than random. It gives us language for patterns we once struggled to name.
The trouble begins when the wall becomes so familiar that we forget it is only one way of seeing.
We stop looking through the window because we become convinced the wall tells us everything we need to know. Instead of opportunities to change, we have cement.
When Self-Explanation Becomes Identity
The most powerful explanations eventually become identities.
"I sometimes avoid conflict" becomes "I'm conflict avoidant."
"I've been working too hard lately" becomes "I'm a workaholic."
"I've learned to earn approval" becomes "I'm a people pleaser."
At first, these labels create clarity. They help us make sense of ourselves and offer language for patterns we couldn't previously name.
Eventually, however, clarity begins to harden into certainty.
Every new experience is filtered through what we already believe about ourselves. Instead of asking, What's happening now? we quietly substitute a different question: How does this fit the story I already know?
The explanation is no longer helping us observe ourselves. It has begun observing on our behalf, becoming the lens through which we interpret both ourselves and the world around us.
Sometimes the explanation becomes something more than a story.
It becomes a hiding place.
Not because we lack courage or motivation, but because explanations can quietly relieve us of the discomfort of change. If "I'm just conflict avoidant" becomes the final answer, there is little reason to risk the difficult conversation. If "That's simply how I'm wired" becomes the conclusion, curiosity gives way to resignation.
The explanation that once created compassion for ourselves can quietly become permission to stay exactly where we are.
What Coaching Through Self-Explanation Looks Like
This is where coaching diverges from analysis. Analysis seeks better explanations. Coaching returns us to present-moment observation.
A client once said, "I know exactly what's happening. I'm avoiding the conversation because I'm conflict avoidant."
It sounded insightful. I could have explored conflict avoidance. Instead, I found myself becoming curious about something else.
"As you say those words, what are you noticing right now?"
The client grew quiet.
After a long pause they smiled.
"Honestly? I think I'm trying to convince you that I understand myself."
That wasn't the insight. It was the beginning of one.
Coaching doesn't ask clients to abandon their explanations. It simply refuses to mistake them for the end of the story. Instead, it gently returns the client's attention to what is unfolding right now, trusting that fresh awareness often emerges from present-moment observation rather than better analysis.
Explanation Is Memory. Observation Is Presence.
Explanation and observation are both valuable, but they serve different purposes.
Explanation organizes yesterday. Observation encounters today.
Explanation says, "I know why I do this."
Observation notices, "I'm doing it again."
One helps us understand ourselves. The other allows us to meet ourselves.
That distinction matters because coaching happens in the present tense. Growth rarely comes from polishing an explanation we already believe. More often, it begins when we notice something we had overlooked only moments before.
This is why the ICF Core Competencies place such emphasis on presence, active listening, and evoking awareness. Coaching is less about arriving at better explanations than creating the conditions for clients to encounter themselves with fresh eyes.
Coaching Through Self-Explanation Means Leaving One Brick Out
Perhaps our work as coaches is not to tear down the wall.
Many of those bricks were earned honestly. They represent courage, healing, reflection, previous coaching, and hard-won wisdom. They deserve to be honored.
Perhaps our work is simply to leave one brick out.
At its heart, coaching through self-explanation isn't about replacing one story with another. It's about creating enough space for clients to notice what their familiar explanations can no longer reveal.
Just enough room for fresh light to enter.
Just enough space for surprise.
Just enough openness to discover that we are still becoming.
Perhaps the opposite of self-explanation is not self-awareness. Perhaps it is self-curiosity. The willingness to become interesting to ourselves again. To notice before we conclude. To observe before we explain.
Because growth rarely begins when we find a better explanation.
More often, it begins when we become willing to look through the opening we almost forgot was there.
Sometimes all it takes is leaving one brick out.
A Reflection for Coaches
Perhaps the greatest gift of mentor coaching isn't learning better questions. It's discovering the places where our own coaching has become familiar.
Most experienced coaches can explain why they ask the questions they ask. We develop trusted frameworks, favorite metaphors, and patterns that serve our clients well. The longer we coach, the more fluent we become in our own way of coaching. Fluency is a gift—but it can also make our habits nearly invisible to us.
Mentor coaching creates a space to observe our coaching with fresh eyes. Not because our coaching is wrong, but because even our strongest habits deserve an occasional moment of curiosity. Sometimes the next level of growth isn't found by adding another technique. It's found by noticing something that has been hiding in plain sight all along.
If you're preparing for an ICF credential or simply wondering what new possibilities might emerge in your coaching, mentor coaching offers a rare opportunity to become interesting to yourself again.

This essay is part of Coaching Through Everything, a series exploring the wonderfully complicated human experiences that find their way into coaching conversations—and what they ask of us as coaches.




