top of page

Coaching Collusion

Nov 9
4 min read

Updated: 2 days ago

Whimsical illustration of two knitted characters sitting together in a cozy room, suggesting how personal patterns intertwine in coaching relationships.
Sometimes the patterns we bring into coaching begin to knit themselves together.

Anyone who has knitted knows that a pattern emerges one stitch at a time. At first, you're paying attention to every movement. Knit, purl, turn. Eventually, your hands find their rhythm, and you can continue almost without thinking.

Occasionally, you discover that you've been repeating the wrong stitch for several rows. Each individual stitch may be perfectly executed, but the emerging pattern is not quite what you intended.

Relationships develop patterns, too.

We learn how to respond to certain people, what they seem to need from us, and which version of ourselves tends to work best with them. Over time, those responses become so familiar that we hardly notice we're making them.

Coaching relationships are no exception.

A client brings their habitual ways of relating to other people into the conversation. We bring ours. And sometimes, without either of us realizing it, we begin knitting a familiar pattern together.

This is one way coaching collusion can happen. Not through deception or deliberate agreement, but through two people participating in a relational dynamic that neither has quite recognized.

And the particularly inconvenient thing about collusion is that it can feel an awful lot like good coaching.

When Coaching Collusion Feels Helpful

Consider a client who is accustomed to taking responsibility for everything. They anticipate problems, fill the gaps, and make sure nothing falls through the cracks. They arrive at coaching exhausted by the demands other people place on them, wondering why they always seem to be the one holding everything together.

The coach listens carefully, recognizes the burden, and begins helping the client sort through their responsibilities. Together, they explore boundaries, expectations, and ways to delegate more effectively. The coach may even find themselves doing a little extra between sessions, searching for resources or thinking about strategies that might help.

The client has come to coaching because they're carrying too much responsibility. Meanwhile, the coach has begun carrying a little extra responsibility for the client's progress.

Apparently, someone has to hold everything together.

Or consider the client who approaches coaching as another opportunity to excel. They arrive prepared, complete every reflection exercise, and enthusiastically request more challenging assignments. The coach responds with increasingly sophisticated questions, additional resources, and ambitious development goals.

Both are enjoying the work. Both are invested in progress. The coaching is productive, the client is delighted, and there's a good chance the coach will receive a glowing testimonial.

Meanwhile, the client's familiar habit of measuring their worth through achievement has quietly become the organizing principle of the coaching relationship.

Neither example necessarily represents poor coaching. The client may be benefiting enormously. But it's worth wondering whether the coaching relationship is creating room to examine a familiar pattern or simply giving it another place to flourish.

The Patterns We Create Together

Psychologists have long recognized that behavior is shaped not only by personality but also by relationships. Interpersonal theories describe how our behavior can invite complementary responses from others, often without either person realizing what's happening.

We're remarkably good at finding people who know how to play their part.

Coaches are no exception. We bring our own habits, preferences, and well-practiced ways of being useful into the conversation. And sometimes those habits fit rather neatly with what a particular client seems to need.

Even our professional strengths can become part of the pattern. The very qualities that make us effective coaches—our empathy, curiosity, resourcefulness, and commitment to helping others grow—can draw us into familiar roles before we've noticed we've accepted them.

The ICF competency Embodies a Coaching Mindset emphasizes reflective practice and self-awareness. We generally think about this as recognizing our biases, managing our emotions, and continuing to develop as coaches.

But it also means becoming curious about the roles we slip into with particular clients.

When the Pattern Includes Us

The ICF competency Evokes Awareness invites coaches to share observations, intuitions, and patterns without attachment. And Maintains Presence asks us to remain open and curious about what is happening in the moment.

We're often quite good at spotting patterns in our clients. Give us someone who repeatedly apologizes before expressing an opinion, and we'll notice the pattern before they've finished apologizing.

But discovering a pattern we're participating in requires a different kind of attention.

When we become aware of our own contribution, the relationship itself becomes part of the coaching conversation, offering a perspective that neither of us could discover quite the same way alone.

Sometimes that awareness leads to an observation we can share.

"I'm noticing that we're working very hard to find the right answer. What's happening for you as we do that?"

The client may recognize something familiar, disagree entirely, or discover something neither of us anticipated. We don't have to interpret the interaction for them.

After all, we're not standing outside the knitting inspecting the client's stitches. Our own hands are involved in making it.

A Reflection for Coaches

One of the difficulties with coaching collusion is that it rarely announces itself. There is no small warning light that flashes when our helpfulness begins reinforcing the very pattern a client wants to change. This is unfortunate, because most of us would probably appreciate one.

And occasionally, the coaching is going so beautifully that it doesn't occur to us to wonder why.

There is something humbling about recognizing that the patterns we're so skilled at noticing in our clients may be unfolding right under our noses, with our enthusiastic participation.

The client brings their patterns into the coaching room. The coach brings theirs. Sometimes those patterns recognize each other before either person does.

Until, one day, we look down at what we've been knitting together.

And wonder how we ended up making the same old sweater.





ICF Mentor Coaching Specialization badge

bottom of page