Independence: Inner Authority
Updated: 2 days ago

Have you ever asked someone for advice about a decision you'd already made?
You explain the situation, listen thoughtfully to their perspective, and thank them for their insight. Then you ask someone else. And possibly someone else after that.
There's nothing inherently wrong with this. When we're facing unfamiliar circumstances or a decision with meaningful consequences, reassurance can be a gift. Someone else's experience may help us recognize possibilities we hadn't considered or give us the encouragement we need to take the next step.
But there's a subtle difference between seeking reassurance and becoming dependent on it. At some point, we may notice that we're no longer gathering useful perspectives. We're waiting for someone else to make the decision feel safe enough to act.
Whose Decision Is It, Anyway?
In the EQ-i 2.0® model of emotional intelligence, developed by Multi-Health Systems, Independence is part of the Self-Expression composite. It concerns our capacity to think and act autonomously, make decisions, and carry out plans without excessive emotional reliance on others.
That doesn't mean making every decision alone. It means being able to exercise our own judgment, even when other people have opinions about what we should do.
Consider the difference between asking a trusted colleague, "What am I missing?" and asking, "Do you think I should do this?"
Either question can be useful. The distinction lies less in the words than in what we're hoping to receive. Are we inviting another perspective to sharpen our thinking, or hoping someone will take responsibility for the choice?
We seek advice for all sorts of reasons. Another person may have expertise we lack, or we may be genuinely uncertain about the best course of action. More awkwardly, we may already know what we want to do but aren't quite ready to live with the consequences.
Our decisions rarely exist in isolation. They affect relationships, careers, families, and communities. We may worry about disappointing someone whose opinion matters deeply to us or challenging expectations we've lived with for years.
In some families and cultures, consulting others is an expression of respect and belonging. In organizations, decisions are often shaped by formal authority, informal influence, and the practical realities of keeping one's job. Seeking agreement isn't necessarily evidence of dependence. It may reflect sound judgment about the environment in which we're operating.
Independence, then, isn't simply a matter of ignoring external expectations. It's recognizing which influences deserve consideration and which have quietly acquired more authority over our choices than we intended.
The Other Side of Independence
There's another way to lose sight of our own judgment: becoming so determined to appear independent that we resist anyone else's influence.
We've probably all encountered someone who treats advice as an unwelcome intrusion. Offer a suggestion, and they're suddenly committed to doing the opposite. Their independence must be defended at all costs, preferably before anyone finishes speaking.
It's a curious paradox. When our choices are organized around proving that no one can influence us, other people are still determining our behavior. We're simply allowing them to do it in reverse.
Stubbornness can look remarkably like independence from a distance.
Genuine independence leaves room for reconsideration. Listening to an opposing view may reveal something we'd overlooked, and changing our minds needn't feel like a defeat. Acknowledging another person's expertise doesn't diminish our ability to think for ourselves.
This matters especially in leadership. A leader who makes every decision without consultation may appear decisive, but the people closest to the work often hold information that leadership needs. Conversely, a leader who continually seeks consensus may struggle to make necessary choices when agreement isn't possible.
Neither independence nor collaboration is particularly useful when treated as a performance. Listening doesn't require us to surrender our judgment, just as making a decision doesn't mean pretending we arrived at it entirely on our own.
Independent, Not Alone
One of the more subtle signs of healthy independence is the ability to accept help without feeling diminished by it.
Asking for guidance, leaning on someone during a difficult season, or acknowledging another person's greater experience needn't compromise our autonomy. Reassurance can help us find our footing, particularly when we're navigating unfamiliar territory. The difficulty arises when we come to believe we cannot take another step without it.
Our relationships often make independent thinking possible. A thoughtful conversation may reveal an assumption, introduce an overlooked possibility, or help us understand why a particular choice matters so much.
The distinction is between allowing others to contribute to our thinking and expecting them to do our thinking for us.
This is where independence and interdependence meet. Trusting ourselves and trusting other people aren't mutually exclusive, although maintaining that balance requires attention.
Consider what happens when we seek another opinion. Does the conversation leave us better informed or simply more reassured? Does disagreement invite reflection, or make it difficult to proceed? When someone offers a perspective we hadn't considered, are we able to welcome it without feeling that our own judgment is somehow flawed?
There won't always be a neat answer. Some decisions deserve considerable consultation. Others require us to recognize that we've gathered enough information and that further discussion is unlikely to resolve the discomfort of choosing.
Eventually, someone has to decide. Most times, that someone is us.
The people around us can help us find our way. They don't have to choose the way for us.
Curious about your own emotional intelligence?
The EQ-i 2.0® Workplace Assessment offers insight into your emotional strengths and opportunities for growth.

Read other essays in the Emotional Intelligence Series.
These reflections are my own interpretation of the EQ-i 2.0® model, developed by Multi-Health Systems (MHS), and do not represent official MHS guidance. Learn more about EQ-i 2.0®.




