Assertiveness: Speaking Up, Staying Open
Updated: 2 days ago

You've been sitting in a meeting, listening carefully as your colleagues discuss an important decision. Something occurs to you. It's a worthwhile observation, perhaps even one that could change the direction of the conversation.
But you want to think it through before speaking. You consider how to phrase it, anticipate possible objections, and search for just the right words.
Meanwhile, the discussion moves along.
And then someone else says almost exactly what you've been thinking.
Everyone nods. Someone calls it a great point. You sit there wondering how they managed to get your carefully considered idea into the conversation before you did.
It's a familiar experience for many thoughtful professionals, particularly those who've been encouraged to "speak up more" in meetings. The challenge isn't necessarily having something to say. It's finding the willingness, and sometimes the opportunity, to say it before every uncertainty has been resolved.
And that brings us to assertiveness.
More Than Speaking Up
In the EQ-i 2.0® framework developed by Multi-Health Systems (MHS), Assertiveness is one of three subscales within the Self-Expression composite. It refers to communicating our feelings, beliefs, and thoughts openly while defending our personal rights and values in a socially acceptable, non-offensive, and non-destructive manner.
Notice what the definition doesn't require. We don't have to be outgoing, particularly vocal, or entirely comfortable with disagreement. Nor does assertiveness depend on having the most persuasive argument in the room.
Yet we often confuse assertiveness with confidence, as though people who speak readily must possess an inner certainty that quieter individuals lack.
Sometimes they do. Sometimes they're simply more comfortable thinking aloud.
For someone who carefully considers every word, contributing an unfinished thought can feel surprisingly risky. What if the idea isn't quite right? What if someone disagrees? What if there's something obvious they've overlooked?
These concerns aren't necessarily unreasonable. In some workplaces, speaking prematurely carries genuine consequences. Organizational culture, power dynamics, and previous experiences all influence how safe it feels to express an opinion.
Still, there's a difference between choosing our moment thoughtfully and waiting for a certainty that may never arrive.
We can have something worthwhile to contribute without knowing exactly how others will receive it.
The Cost of Keeping the Peace
For those who prefer to keep the peace, assertiveness can present a different challenge. They may know perfectly well what they think, what they need, or where a boundary belongs. They simply don't want to deal with the friction that might follow.
So they agree to something they'd rather decline, remain silent about a concern, or accommodate a request that stretches them further than they'd like.
In the moment, this can feel like the easier choice. The conversation stays pleasant. Nobody argues. Everyone moves on.
But avoiding the immediate discomfort doesn't necessarily eliminate the cost. Sometimes it simply spreads that cost over the following days or weeks, in the form of additional work, quiet resentment, or the energy required to keep accommodating something that never felt quite right.
There's a peculiar irony in trying to conserve energy by avoiding a difficult conversation, only to spend considerably more of it managing the consequences.
Of course, not every disagreement deserves our attention, and choosing to accommodate someone can be an entirely reasonable expression of generosity. Sometimes the circumstances, including differences in power or the consequences of speaking, warrant caution.
The distinction lies in whether we're making a conscious choice or habitually trading our own needs for a moment of peace.
And this is where the second half of the EQ-i definition becomes especially important: defending our personal rights and values.
The word defending can sound rather combative, as though we need to prepare for battle whenever someone asks something of us. But assertiveness doesn't require confrontation. It may simply mean explaining a concern, declining a request, or standing behind a decision that others would prefer us to reconsider.
We can be respectful without being agreeable, acknowledging another person's perspective without surrendering our own. And a little friction isn't necessarily evidence that something has gone wrong.
When Conviction Becomes Certainty
There's another side to this conversation, particularly for people who have little difficulty expressing themselves.
Consider a leader who speaks confidently, challenges assumptions, and readily advocates for a position. These can be valuable qualities, especially when difficult decisions need to be made.
But what happens when that confidence leaves little room for other perspectives?
Perhaps the leader responds to every objection with a stronger argument, or listens primarily for weaknesses in someone else's reasoning. Over time, colleagues may have learned that disagreeing requires considerably more energy than quietly going along.
The leader may believe they're encouraging vigorous discussion. Everyone else may have reached a different conclusion.
A strength in assertiveness can become a liability when expressing our position begins to matter more than understanding the perspectives around us.
This doesn't mean we should abandon our convictions whenever someone disagrees. There are times when standing firm is entirely appropriate, even necessary.
But defending a belief and defending our need to be right aren't quite the same thing.
We can advocate for a position while remaining curious about what we might be missing, and disagree respectfully without treating another person's perspective as something to overcome. Changing our minds needn't mean abandoning our convictions.
Sometimes assertiveness requires the courage to speak. At other times, it requires enough security in our own position to listen.
Assert: Enter the Conversation
There's still that thoughtful professional sitting in the meeting, watching someone else offer the idea they've been carefully preparing.
Next time, they might speak a little sooner, before they've polished every word or anticipated every objection. Their colleagues may welcome the contribution, even in its unfinished state. Or they might find themselves reconsidering an idea they were rather pleased with five minutes earlier.
Either way, they've entered the conversation.
The same courage serves us when we express a need, question a decision, or stand behind something we value. We can tolerate a little friction without treating it as a threat to the relationship. And we can listen to another perspective without surrendering our own.
Having a voice doesn't mean we always need to use it. Nor does it mean we need the last word.
There's room for our perspective alongside everyone else's.
Curious about your own emotional intelligence?
The EQ-i 2.0® Workplace Assessment offers insight into your emotional strengths and opportunities for growth.

Read other essays in the Emotional Intelligence Series.
These reflections are my own interpretation of the EQ-i 2.0® model, developed by Multi-Health Systems (MHS), and do not represent official MHS guidance. Learn more about EQ-i 2.0®.




