top of page

Empathy: Understanding Without Assuming

Nov 12
4 min read

Updated: 2 days ago

Pair of tan suede ankle boots with dark soles against a pale, neutral background.
Walking in someone else's shoes may help us understand their experience. But we still bring our own feet.

Most of us have experienced the awkwardness of trying to comfort someone and discovering that our well-intentioned response wasn't particularly comforting.

A friend shares something painful, and we offer reassurance. A colleague expresses frustration, and we begin suggesting solutions. Someone describes a difficult experience, and we recognize something familiar from our own lives. Before they've finished speaking, we're halfway through a story about what happened to us.

Our intentions are usually good. We care, we want to help, and sometimes we genuinely believe we understand. Yet there's a subtle difference between recognizing something familiar in another person's experience and understanding what that experience means to them.

Understanding Another's Experience

In the EQ-i 2.0® model, Empathy is one of three subscales within the Interpersonal composite. It concerns our ability to recognize, understand, and appreciate how other people feel.

The definition sounds straightforward enough. The practice is considerably more complicated.

We sometimes describe empathy as putting ourselves in someone else's shoes. It's a useful image, although it has its limitations. We bring our own feet, after all, along with our histories, assumptions, and ideas about how we might respond in similar circumstances.

Someone else's disappointment may remind us of a time we felt overlooked. Their anxiety may seem familiar because we've faced comparable uncertainty. These connections can help us relate, but they can also lead us to assume that what mattered to us must matter equally to them.

Empathy asks us to remain curious about the difference.

Sympathy has a place here, too. Feeling concern or sorrow for someone who's struggling is a genuine expression of care. Empathy adds an interest in understanding their particular experience, even when their feelings differ from what we might expect or experience ourselves.

We don't have to feel the same emotion to appreciate its significance.

When Our Understanding Gets in the Way

One of the more curious things about human relationships is how quickly we can become convinced that we know what someone is feeling.

A colleague grows quiet during a meeting. We assume they're upset. A friend declines an invitation, and we wonder whether we've offended them. Someone responds sharply to an innocent question, and we decide they're being unreasonable.

Our interpretations may be accurate. But the colleague might simply be thinking, the friend might be tired, and the sharp response might have nothing to do with us.

We rarely have access to the whole story, although that doesn't always prevent us from writing one.

Our judgments can become particularly persuasive when we recognize a familiar pattern. Experience helps us notice emotional cues, but it can also encourage us to settle on an explanation before we've understood what matters to the other person.

Curiosity offers another possibility.

Rather than assuming someone is frustrated, we might ask how they're experiencing the situation. Instead of deciding that a friend needs encouragement, we might listen long enough to discover whether they're looking for reassurance, understanding, practical help, or simply some company.

Even then, we may misunderstand. Empathy isn't mind-reading, and asking a thoughtful question doesn't guarantee an accurate interpretation. Sometimes the most respectful response is to acknowledge that we haven't quite understood and invite the other person to tell us more.

There's a certain humility in allowing someone else's experience to remain different from our own.

Caring Without Taking Over

Understanding becomes more complicated when someone we care about is struggling.

Discomfort can awaken our desire to make things better. We offer perspective, remind someone of their strengths, or suggest a solution that seems perfectly reasonable from where we're sitting.

Sometimes that's exactly what's needed. Practical help can be a deeply empathetic response, particularly when someone is overwhelmed or has explicitly asked for assistance.

At other times, our eagerness to help moves the conversation away from something the other person hasn't finished expressing.

Consider a leader whose employee is disappointed about a missed opportunity. The leader might immediately explain the decision, identify future possibilities, or encourage the employee to focus on what comes next. All reasonable responses, perhaps, but none necessarily acknowledges what the disappointment means to that individual.

Understanding may require a little patience before moving toward solutions.

There's another complication. When someone's distress touches something painful in our own experience, we may find ourselves feeling unusually anxious, sad, or responsible. Our emotional response is real, but it isn't necessarily a reliable guide to what the other person needs.

Caring doesn't require us to absorb another person's emotions or assume responsibility for resolving them. Nor does empathy demand unlimited emotional availability. Sometimes we can offer thoughtful attention; at other times, our own circumstances or emotional capacity require boundaries.

Those boundaries needn't diminish our concern. They can help us remain connected without losing sight of where one person's experience ends and ours begins.

The Humanity of Empathy

I think empathy is sometimes made unnecessarily complicated by our efforts to demonstrate it. We learn reflective phrases, practice attentive listening, and try to respond in ways that communicate understanding. These can be useful habits, but even a beautifully worded reflection can miss the mark when it rests on an assumption.

Human connection rarely follows a script.

Some people appreciate having their feelings acknowledged. Others prefer quiet companionship, practical assistance, or the freedom to speak without having every emotion named and examined. And occasionally, what someone needs most is for us to accept that they don't want to talk about it.

Empathy invites us to pay attention to the person rather than our preferred way of showing care.

We won't always understand what someone is experiencing. Differences in history, culture, identity, circumstances, and temperament shape how people encounter the world. Even those closest to us remain capable of surprising us.

Perhaps the deeper expression of empathy isn't being able to say, "I know exactly how you feel."

It's being willing to discover that we don't—and remaining interested in understanding anyway.



Curious about your own emotional intelligence?

The EQ-i 2.0® Workplace Assessment offers insight into your emotional strengths and opportunities for growth.



EQ-i 2.0 Certified badge

Read other essays in the Emotional Intelligence Series.

These reflections are my own interpretation of the EQ-i 2.0® model, developed by Multi-Health Systems (MHS), and do not represent official MHS guidance. Learn more about EQ-i 2.0®.

bottom of page