More Than Coaching Technique
Updated: 3 days ago

There's an interesting tension at the heart of coaching. We spend considerable time learning what to do: how to listen, ask thoughtful questions, challenge assumptions, and support meaningful action. Yet some of the most important things we bring to a coaching conversation have less to do with technique than with how we understand the person sitting across from us.
We may ask a beautifully constructed question while privately hoping for a particular answer. Or sit quietly with a client, resisting the urge to intervene, and discover that our presence offers more than the question we were preparing to ask.
My Co-Active® training introduced me to the relationship between being and doing in coaching. That distinction has stayed with me, although my understanding of it has evolved through experience. I've become increasingly interested in what influences our choice to use a particular skill—and what happens when we're no longer consciously choosing.
When Technique Takes Over
Especially early in our development, practicing these skills can occupy a remarkable amount of mental space. We're listening to the client while considering what to ask, what we've noticed, and whether we're applying what we've learned. We want to be helpful, and naturally, we want to know we're doing the work well.
The difficulty arises when monitoring our technique begins to compete with our attention to the client. We become preoccupied with whether our next question will be sufficiently powerful or whether the conversation is progressing as it should.
We can look remarkably attentive while conducting an entirely different conversation in our heads.
Our desire to be useful can be especially persuasive. A client describes a familiar challenge, and we recognize something that helped another person in a similar situation. An insight comes to mind. We begin imagining where the conversation could go.
Experience may be offering something valuable. But there's a difference between having a useful perspective and becoming invested in delivering it.
The challenge isn't to stop thinking or suppress our professional judgment. It's to notice when our attention has shifted from what the client is exploring to what we're hoping to contribute.
The Same Skill, a Different Experience
Consider something as familiar as asking an open-ended question.
A client pauses after acknowledging that an important decision feels more complicated than they expected. We might ask what they're noticing, invite them to consider another perspective, or remain quiet.
Each response could be useful. None is inherently the right one.
A thoughtful question might help the client explore something they haven't considered. It could also interrupt a reflection that was developing quite well without our assistance.
Silence may offer space to think. Or the client may be waiting for clarification, uncertain about where the conversation is going.
We cannot determine the most helpful response simply by consulting our repertoire of coaching techniques.
Much depends on what we're noticing, what we understand about the client, and what we've agreed to work toward. Our reactions matter, too. Are we asking another question because the client seems ready to explore, or because we're uncomfortable with the pause?
We won't always recognize the distinction in the moment. And even when we make a thoughtful choice, the client may experience our contribution differently than we intended.
An observation we consider perceptive may be of little interest to them. A question that worked beautifully yesterday may accomplish very little today.
That's useful information, provided we're willing to receive it.
The Judgment Behind Coaching Techniques
As we develop our coaching skills, we move from thinking carefully about what we're doing toward a more natural fluency. What once required deliberate concentration becomes familiar, leaving more attention available for the person we're coaching.
The familiar progression from conscious incompetence through conscious competence to unconscious competence helps explain this change.
Yet unconscious competence has an interesting complication. A skill can become so familiar that we stop noticing when we're using it—or questioning whether it serves the moment.
A coach adept at asking evocative questions may reach for one almost automatically. Someone skilled at recognizing patterns may offer an interpretation before considering whether the client would find it useful. Even silence, which we learn to appreciate, can become something we employ because we believe good coaches are comfortable with it.
Our strengths can become habits, and habits don't always invite examination.
This doesn't mean we should return to scrutinizing every move. That would leave us rather occupied with ourselves, which is hardly the point.
Instead, experience offers an opportunity to develop a different relationship with our skills. We can use them with increasing ease while remaining willing to reconsider a familiar response when the moment calls for something else.
Fluency gives us greater freedom. Discernment asks us to remain thoughtful about how we use it.
Perhaps that's what lies beyond coaching technique. Not a stage at which we've outgrown our skills, but the capacity to recognize when they serve the client—and when something else may be needed.
Our techniques remain part of the craft. The work is learning to use them with enough skill that we can give our attention to the person, rather than the technique.





