Holding the Client’s Agenda: Coaching Beyond the Surface
Updated: Oct 23, 2025

Picture a fishing bobber floating on a still lake. It bobs gently, responding to every ripple, every small movement on the surface. But beneath the water, unseen forces are at play—currents shift, fish move, and something deeper is stirring.
In coaching, the client’s immediate concerns are like that bobber, moving with the waves of day-to-day life. But the real agenda—the deeper current—is what shapes transformation. Great coaches don’t just track the surface movement; they help clients sense what’s happening underneath, inviting them into the depth where real change begins.
The Art of Holding the Agenda
One of the most essential skills in Co-Active Coaching is holding the client’s agenda—and that doesn’t mean simply following wherever the client’s topic leads. It means holding space for two levels of focus:
The “little a” agenda — the immediate topic or task at hand (e.g., “I need to prepare for a difficult conversation”).
The “Big A” Agenda — the deeper current of growth and meaning (e.g., “I want to trust my own voice as a leader”).
You can think of the “little a” as the domain of performance coaching—working on goals, actions, and tangible results. The “Big A” sits squarely in developmental coaching—the exploration of identity, mindset, and being. If you’d like to explore that distinction more deeply, you can read my upcoming companion article, Performance vs. Developmental Coaching.
The magic of coaching lies in holding both at once: addressing what’s on the surface while staying attuned to the deeper current of transformation below.
Reading the Ripples and the Current
When clients arrive with a “little a” agenda, it often looks like the shiny lure at the end of the line—something specific, concrete, and easy to grab onto. Yet beneath that surface issue swims the “Big A” Agenda: the deeper current of meaning, growth, or identity that gives their actions shape.
Your task as coach isn’t to tug the line toward depth before the client’s ready, nor to skim endlessly along the surface. It’s to sense both levels at once—tracking the movement of the bobber and the pull of the water below. That’s where presence, partnership, and artistry converge.
Below are three moments that demonstrate how to stay with the client’s presenting topic while skillfully inviting awareness of the current underneath. Each illustrates how the ICF Core Competencies—especially Maintains Presence, Listens Actively, and Evokes Awareness—come alive in practice.
🎣 Scenario: Inviting the Bigger Agenda
Sometimes the client’s words skim the surface like a skipping stone, but the coach’s ear is tuned to the quiet tug beneath the surface agenda.
Client: “I need help figuring out how to word an email to my team about an upcoming deadline.”
Coach: “Got it. Before we dive into the wording, what’s the bigger challenge underneath?”
Client: (Pauses) “…I’m worried they won’t respect me as a leader.”
Coach: “It takes courage to admit that. Would you like to talk about how respect influences your leadership style — even beyond this email?”
Here, the coach recognizes the tactical “little a” (the email) but opens the conversation to include the “Big A” (self-trust and leadership). The focus expands from performance to development—an example of Evokes Awareness in action. The coach partners with the client to explore beyond the surface, inviting reflection and ownership rather than supplying answers or edits.
Coaching Move: When a client focuses on a tactical issue, ask: “What’s the deeper challenge underneath this?”
🎣 Scenario: When the Client Wants to Stay in the Weeds
Some clients cling to the comfort of tasks and to-do lists, preferring productivity to vulnerability.
Client: “Can we just go over my to-do list? I have so much to get done.”
Coach: “Of course. And before we do that, what would having all these tasks done give you?”
Client: (Quietly) “…I guess I’d finally feel like I was enough.”
Coach: “I noticed your voice dropped as you said that. What does 'being enough' mean to you?”
The coach’s curiosity opens the door to meaning-making, gently uncovering the “Big A” beneath the task-driven agenda. This is Maintains Presence at work—staying engaged with the client’s growth even when they resist it, and trusting that the invitation to depth will arise when they’re ready.
Coaching Move: When a client wants to stay on the surface, ask: “What’s important about this to you?”
🎣 Scenario: Balancing Both Agendas at Once
Skilled coaching means holding the "little a" agenda while anchoring the client in their "Big A" transformation.
Client: “I have a presentation coming up, and I need help preparing.”
Coach: “Great! Let’s work on that. And since public speaking has come up before, how does this connect with your bigger goal of owning your voice?”
The coach balances both agendas seamlessly—addressing the practical need while anchoring in the deeper journey. That’s Cultivates Trust and Safety in motion: honoring the client’s stated goal while holding a wider arc of growth.
At the PCC and MCC levels, this kind of dual awareness is essential. The coach partners with the client not just on what they want to accomplish but who they are becoming in the process.
Coaching Move: When addressing a tactical issue, tie it back to the client’s overarching personal development.
Coaching Beyond the Surface Agenda
Holding the agenda isn’t about steering or controlling. It’s about partnership—helping clients see that their day-to-day ripples are shaped by deeper currents. When you attune to both, you invite transformation without abandoning practicality.
Next time you’re in session, notice where your client’s “bobber” is floating—but listen for what’s moving beneath. That’s where real insight, confidence, and self-leadership emerge.
Reflection for Coaches
How easily do you notice when the client’s “little a” agenda begins to drift into their “Big A”?
What cues—tone, emotion, pacing—help you recognize that shift?
When do you catch yourself coaching to the problem, rather than partnering with the person?
This kind of awareness refines your artistry. It’s where technique meets intuition, and where the ICF competencies of Presence, Active Listening, and Evoking Awareness become less about skill and more about being.
🎣 Next Steps
If you’re currently in Co-Active Coach Training or preparing for your ICF credential, mentor coaching can help you strengthen this skill—holding both the tactical and transformational agendas with fluidity and confidence.
Disclaimer: I’m an ICF Master Certified Coach and a Certified Co-Active Coach. This article draws on both the ICF Core Competencies and the Co-Active Coaching model, reflecting my own interpretation and application of these frameworks in practice.




